Click on opponent for opponent Website, score for results
| Date | Opponent | Record | Time/Score |
| March 8-12 | Rebel Spring Games at Kissimmee, Fla. | - | TBA |
| 8 | Benedictine (OCSC 3) | 0-1 | L, 3-1 |
| 8 | Greensboro (OCSC 3) - Day one recap | 0-2 | L, 5-1 |
| 9 | Thomas More (FR 2) | 1-2 | W, 7-2 |
| 9 | Ursinus (FR 2) - Recap | 1-3 | L, 7-1 |
| 10 | Carthage (OCSC 3) | 1-4 | L, 2-0 |
| 10 | Missouri Baptist (OCSC 3) - Recap | 1-5 | L, 5-2 |
| 11 | Coe (OB 2) (OSCS) - Recap | 1-6 | L, 4-2 (8) |
| 11 | Albion (OB 2) | - | Canceled |
| 12 | Wittenberg (FR 2) | - | Canceled |
| 12 | Simpson (FR 2) | - | Canceled |
| 18 | at Adrian - Recap | 1-7 1-8 |
L, 6-0 L, 5-2 |
| 19 | TRINE - Recap | 1-9 1-10 |
L, 11-3 L, 5-4 |
| 26 | ALMA | - | Postponed |
| 27 | at Hanover* - HCAC Series Preview Recap |
2-10, 1-0 HCAC 3-10, 2-0 HCAC |
W, 13-0 (5) W, 3-2 |
| 30 | at Defiance* - HCAC Series Preview Recap |
4-10, 3-0 HCAC 5-10, 4-0 HCAC |
W, 6-1 W, 8-0 (6) |
| April 2 | at Kenyon - Recap | 5-11 6-11 |
L, 6-2 W, 6-5 |
| 3 | FRANKLIN* - HCAC Series Preview Recap |
7-11, 5-0 HCAC 8-11, 6-0 HCAC |
W, 9-0 (5) W, 14-0 (5) |
| 7 | ROSE-HULMAN* HCAC Series Preview |
- | Postponed |
| 9 | at Mt. St. Joseph* HCAC Series Preview - Recap |
9-11, 7-0 HCAC 10-11, 8-0 HCAC |
W, 7-0 W, 9-2 |
| 10 | at Transylvania* HCAC Series Preview - Recap |
10-12, 8-1 HCAC 10-13, 8-2 HCAC |
L, 6-3 L, 8-0 (6) |
| 13 | OHIO WESLEYAN - Recap | 10-14 11-14 |
L, 4-1 W, 3-2 |
| 17 | at Ursuline - Recap | 11-15 12-15 |
L, 2-1 W, 3-2 |
| 21 | HEIDELBERG - Recap | 12-16 13-16 |
L, 3-2 W, 7-3 |
| 22 | OHIO NORTHERN - Recap | 13-17 14-17 |
L, 13-2 (5) W, 4-2 |
| 24 | ANDERSON* (Strike-Out Cancer Day) Click here to sponsor a player HCAC Series Preview |
- | Postponed |
| 25 | ROSE-HULMAN* - Recap HCAC Series Preview |
14-18, 8-3 HCAC 15-18, 9-3 HCAC |
L, 5-2 W, 7-0 |
| 27 | ANDERSON* (Strike-Out Cancer Day) HCAC Series Preview - Recap |
16-18, 10-3 HCAC 16-19, 10-4 HCAC |
W, 7-6 L, 5-4 (8) |
| 28 | MANCHESTER* (Senior/Parent Day) HCAC Series Preview - Recap |
16-20, 10-5 HCAC 17-20, 11-5 HCAC |
L, 6-3 W, 6-5 |
| May 7-8 | HCAC Tournament at Transylvania Tournament Website - Preview #2 Bluffton vs. #3 Anderson Recap |
18-20 | W, 7-2 |
| 7 | #2 Bluffton vs. Transylvania Recap |
18-21 | L, 10-3 |
| 8 | #2 Bluffton vs. #4 Manchester Recap |
18-22 | L, 11-4 |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference contest
Home games in bold and all CAPS
Click here for 2009 schedule and results
