Click on opponent for opponent Website and score for results
| Date | Opponent | Record | Time/Result |
| Nov. 17 | THOMAS MORE - Recap | 0-1 | L, 90-78 |
| 20 | at Albion Tournament vs. DePauw - Recap | 0-2 | L, 50-45 |
| 21 | at Albion Tournament vs. Edgewood - Recap | 0-3 | L, 71-53 |
| 24 | at Trine - Recap | 0-4 | L, 50-46 |
| 28 | ADRIAN - Recap | 0-5 | L, 65-52 |
| Dec. 2 | at Mt. St. Joseph* - Recap | 0-6, 0-1 HCAC | L, 58-44 |
| 5 | at Transylvania* - Recap | 0-7, 0-2 HCAC | L, 54-49 |
| 9 | ANDERSON* - Recap | 0-8, 0-3 HCAC | L, 68-47 |
| 12 | FRANKLIN* - Recap | 0-9, 0-4 HCAC | L, 61-59 |
| 19 | HIRAM - Live Stats - Recap | 0-10 | L, 71-64 (OT) |
| 29 | McDonald's Holiday Tournament | - | 6/8 PM |
| 29 | Goshen College def. Illinois College | - | GC, 95-79 |
| 29 | Bluffton vs. UC-Clermont - Recap | 0-11 | L, 82-63 |
| 30 | McDonald's Holiday Tournament | - | 1/3 PM |
| 30 | Bluffton vs. Illinois College - Recap | 0-12 | L, 65-50 |
| 30 | Goshen College def. UC-Clermont | - | GC, 90-84 |
| Jan. 2 | at Kalamazoo - Recap | 0-13 | L, 49-45 |
| 6 | HANOVER* - Recap | 0-14, 0-5 HCAC | L, 63-57 |
| 9 | at Rose-Hulman* - Recap | 0-15, 0-6 HCAC | L, 68-60 |
| 13 | at Manchester* - Recap | 0-16, 0-7 HCAC | L, 70-61 |
| 20 | DEFIANCE* - Recap | 1-16, 1-7 HCAC | W, 91-83 |
| 23 | TRANSYLVANIA* - Recap (Alumni Day) | 1-17, 1-8 HCAC | L, 69-66 |
| 27 | MOUNT ST JOSEPH* - Recap | 2-17, 2-8 HCAC | W, 77-63 |
| 30 | at Franklin* - Recap | 2-18, 2-9 HCAC | L, 62-59 |
| Feb. 3 | at Anderson* - Recap | 2-19, 2-10 HCAC | L, 72-66 |
| 6 | at Hanover* - Recap | 2-20, 2-11 HCAC | L, 72-67 |
| 10 | MANCHESTER* - Recap | 2-21, 2-12 HCAC | L, 60-51 |
| 13 | ROSE-HULMAN* (Senior Day) - Recap | 2-22, 2-13 HCAC | L, 65-62 |
| 17 | at Defiance* - Game Preview - Recap | 2-23, 2-14 HCAC | L, 70-60 |
| 23-27 | HCAC Tournament | - | TBA |
Home games in bold and all CAPS
* Indicates Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference contest
WBWH indicates game will be broadcast by Bluffton University campus radio 99.3
Click here for 2008-09 schedule and results