| Date | Location | Result | |
| 11-14-09 | Defiance, OH | Defiance 35, Bluffton University 0 | Box score |
| 11-07-09 | Hanover, Ind. | Hanover 52, Bluffton University 19 | Box score |
| 10-31-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Anderson University 28, Bluffton University 3 | Box score |
| 10-24-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Rose-Hulman 50, Bluffton University 14 | Box score |
| 10-17-09 | N. Manchester, Ind. | Manchester 23, Bluffton University 7 | Box score |
| 10-10-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Franklin College 28, Bluffton University 12 | Box score |
| 10-03-09 | Cincinnati, OH | Mount St. Joseph 38, Bluffton University 18 | Box score |
| 09-26-09 | Kalamazoo, Mich. | Kalamazoo College 47, Bluffton University 27 | Box score |
| 09-19-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Adrian College 41, Bluffton University 7 | Box score |
| 09-05-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Alma College 28, Bluffton University 16 | Box score |